Can ‘Law & Order’ outlive ‘Gunsmoke’?
NEW YORK – “POPPA DON’T TAKE NO MESS!”
The outburst comes from Anthony Anderson, who is describing the essential qualities of Kevin Bernard, the latest detective to join NBC-TV’s long-running “Law & Order.” The fun-loving and funny Anderson debuted last season as Bernard and resumes busting bad guys on Wednesday, Nov. 5, 10 p.m. EST (in Canada the premiere airs Tuesday, Nov. 4 at 9 p.m.).
If Anderson has an off-camera “off switch,” it’s nowhere to be found this day as he shoots scenes inside Silver Screen Studios at Chelsea Piers, which houses the crime drama’s precinct, district attorney’s office, courthouse, prison and morgue. He bellows throughout the day, at one point jokingly scolding a crew member, “GET OFF THE TELEPHONE, WOMAN!” And he even speaks in tongues – “TELEMUNDO! OH, THIS IS A TELENOVELA!” – to describe an episode’s plot twist involving double murder, DNA evidence and an illicit affair.
Anderson’s outsized personality doubtless proved a draw for show creator Dick Wolf, who cast him as Detective Cyrus Lupo’s (Jeremy Sisto) partner. Wolf hand-picks each police detective and prosecutor on “Law & Order,” and deemed Anderson a “natural” successor to Detective Ed Green (Jesse L. Martin), citing his comic timing, screen presence and acting chops.
Another factor? Youth.
Anderson, 38, follows Sisto, 34, and Linus Roache, 44, as the third in a swift succession of young actors – well, young by “Law & Order” standards – recruited by Wolf for the 18th season, which concluded in May. The venerable series is a recent victim of near-cancellation, and fresh blood could be just the bait needed to lure the younger viewers that advertisers love and keep the show going for another two decades.
“Law & Order” is returning to the air earlier than the announced date of early 2009, the result of an NBC schedule reshuffling to shore up the network’s ratings as sweeps month begins. After almost two decades, this durable old veteran still has the juice to help rescue NBC’s prime-time.
The new season has S. Epatha Merkerson (Lieut. Anita Van Buren) remaining on duty, overseeing Sisto and Anderson; Roache as Chief Assistant District Attorney Michael Cutter, who succeeded Jack McCoy (Sam Waterston), the newly promoted district attorney. And Alana De La Garza (Executive Assistant District Attorney Connie Rubirosa) resumes her role.
But it remains to be seen whether the cast reshuffling will achieve Wolf’s greatest ambition: to surpass “Gunsmoke” as the longest-running prime-time drama in the history of television.
Wolf, 61, has long voiced his desire to overtake the classic Western, which ran from 1955-1975 on CBS; Wednesday’s season premiere will herald 19 years for “Law & Order.” “It’s one to tie and two to win. I think after that, (we’ll do) another 20,” Wolf said.
But the TV mogul, who oversees the spinoffs “Law & Order: SVU” and “Law & Order: Criminal Intent,” nearly lost his chance when NBC threatened to cancel after a sharp ratings drop last season.
Any plug-pulling seems preposterous, given the series’ enduring status as the mother ship of one of the strongest franchises on TV. Wolf struck a last-minute deal to save the show in May 2007 by trading “Criminal Intent” to the NBC-owned USA Network in exchange for another year of “Law & Order” on the Peacock Network.
As it happens, the original series fared well in its 18th season: It debuted in January amid the writers strike with fresh episodes, and averaged a total 10.7 million viewers. That’s a major jump, up 19 per cent from the previous season (nine million average viewers), according to NBC ratings expert Tom Bierbaum.
It’s also a positive sign for a show that peaked in its 2001-02 season with an average viewership of 18.7 million, and has steadily decreased in the ratings as TV began losing viewers to the Internet and other digital phenomena.
Waterston attributed the audience bump to the show’s move to Wednesday from Friday, one of the least-watched nights on TV, and to Wolf’s talents at keeping it fresh without tinkering too visibly with a tried-and-true format.
“He’s a magician. … He changed the look of the show, he changed the way it’s lit, he changed the way it’s shot and the way it’s edited, but not so that you go, ‘Oh this is not the same show.’ But it’s all refreshed,” said the 67-year-old actor, citing the increased practice of shooting scenes from different angles and lighting scenarios to provide more options in the editing room.
Waterston, a series veteran alongside Merkerson, takes a laissez-faire approach to the health of the show (“I’m fine with whatever happens”) but he’d like to beat the “Gunsmoke” record.
“The only reason for me to care about whether this show lasts or not is the absurd goal of beating ‘Gunsmoke,’ and that’s too much fun as an idea to want it to be defeated by the fact that there’s a temporary dip in the ratings here and there,” he said, with a laugh.
Dipping into the fountain of youthful actors could help Wolf achieve that goal.
If “Law & Order” has a weakness, it’s that its core audience – boomers who value a good whodunit – skews outside the target 18-49 demographic coveted by advertisers, said TV historian Tim Brooks, who compared the show to non-glitzy, well-written mysteries such as “Matlock” and “Murder, She Wrote” – and “a comfortable old shoe.”
That’s not a bad thing, though. It provides stability for NBC, which continues to struggle in the ratings, and has also grown a following in syndication on cable; on any given night, viewers can find “Law & Order” on TNT, and “SVU” and “Criminal Intent” on the USA and Bravo networks.
“Law & Order” pioneered the concept of the TV franchise by extending the brand to “SVU,” “Criminal Intent” and the short-lived “Trial by Jury.” It inspired copycats including CBS’ “CSI: Crime Scene Investigation.”
Wolf is the Great Oz behind the business model. The New York-born guru started as an East Coast ad man, writing commercials for brands that included Crest toothpaste, before heading to Hollywood to pursue a career in entertainment. He eventually became one of the industry’s biggest players, producing feature films and writing for “Hill Street Blues”; in 1988, he formed his own production company, Wolf Films, and debuted “Law & Order” two years later.
Wolf, who milked a TV empire from the show, said the reason it has remained on the air so long rests with its self-contained, plot-driven formula.
“You don’t have to see it for a week, a month, a year,” said Wolf, who’s based in Los Angeles. “You come back into a totally complete hour of television with a beginning, middle and an end, and hopefully, a satisfying conclusion. And you can go on your merry way and, if you catch it two years later, it can be a completely different cast. But it still works as exactly the same.”
Despite cast turnover, “Law & Order” has retained its tradition of using real-life headlines and twisting them into dramatic plot lines. Wednesday’s show delivers a thriller of messy elegance as the detectives and attorneys clash over McCoy’s bold move to classify a bloody street fight as a terrorist attack; in this case, the viewer is treated as a jury member, forced to decide between two convincing arguments.
The first victim: A stockbroker beaten to death in broad daylight. “In this economy, this is the kind of thing that might catch on,” quips Bernard upon inspecting the body.
The episode could easily be one of the show’s greatest hits, with strong writing that continues the creative momentum of last season’s finale in which McCoy wrestled with a prostitution scandal involving a New York governor (hints of former Gov. Eliot Spitzer).
The final word on cast changes rests with Wolf, who reserves the power to hire – and veto – the actors and actresses working full-time in the 27th Precinct and the DA’s office.
But he couldn’t control the nine-year itch of Martin, who decided to depart his popular role in the middle of last season because he “was just feeling really burned out,” Wolf said.
Enter Anderson. The actor makes No. 11 in a long succession of police detectives: George Dzundza, Chris Noth, Paul Sorvino, Jerry Orbach, Benjamin Bratt, Martin, Dennis Farina, Michael Imperioli, Milena Govich and Sisto. Anderson grabbed Wolf’s attention playing tough cops in the Oscar-winning film “The Departed,” the former Fox series “K-Ville” and in a guest spot on “SVU.”
Once Martin backed out, Wolf made a play last fall for Anderson, wooing the actor over lunch at the Beverly Hills Hotel amid the Hollywood writers strike. Anderson’s police drama “K-Ville,” set in New Orleans, shuttered production during the strike, and lasted half a season before Fox pulled it from the schedule.
By the end of the meeting, Anderson recalled Wolf dispensing advice on moving his family from Los Angeles to New York – without so much as a “you’re hired.”
“And I was like, ‘Did he? Was this like a Jedi mind trick? Did he just tell me I got the job without telling me the job is mine?’ I think he did,”‘ says Anderson, who has also appeared in “Transformers,” “Hustle & Flow” and TV’s “The Shield.”
Wolf likened Anderson to the late Jerry Orbach, who delivered one-liners with a wink as Detective Lennie Briscoe from 1991-2004.
“He has the ability in terms of his wry observations to bring the same type of rhythm to certain scenes that Jerry did,” he said. “And not to compare them as actors, but it’s great to have somebody who has mastered the art of comic timing.”
But while Orbach’s Briscoe was warm and comforting, Anderson’s Bernard can be cool and combative.
“There’s something innately likable about him and, at the same time, innately tough and innately ‘cop,”‘ said executive producer Fred Berner. “And that combination is kind of fun to watch and dangerous all at the same time. As a human being and an actor, he’s a total joy. And as a character, he’s beginning to find his sea legs.”
His chemistry with the understated Sisto is a plus.
“The secret of partners is always to have ideally one be the yang to somebody else’s yin, and I think that they are really very complementary to each other,” Wolf said.
Wolf also sees a good yin-yang balance between De La Garza, 32, and new hire Roache, who has shown off Cutter’s cocky side.
“He’s a huge find,” Wolf said of the British actor, who has big shoes to fill following Waterston. “He has really brought Alana into a whole other level. The dynamic between the two of them is terrific.”
Waterston, meanwhile, has settled nicely into his new gig as district attorney. Initially, he wasn’t so sure he’d enjoy the upgrade after standing up to the lions of injustice for 13 years as Jack McCoy.
“I pretty categorically had said I was never going to (accept the job),” said Waterston, who envisioned he’d portray the Executive Assistant District Attorney as long as the show ran or until he wanted out.
He also thought McCoy himself might disapprove, given the character’s strong moral compass and disdain for the politics that come with the high-level position.
But Wolf and executive producer Rene Balcer persuaded him to take the bigger office.
“They were both extremely generous and very smart with me,” Waterston recalled. “They said that it was up to me, I could do whatever I wanted. And then they sort of dangled the enticement of more free time in front of me and made it sound like that might be kind of nice.”
When asked if his seniority had anything to do with his promotion, Waterston laughed and said: “The word ‘age’ didn’t cross anybody’s lips.”
Wolf said it’s a natural progression for McCoy – and for Waterston.
“(He) said, ‘I don’t know. I’m not killing the bull every week,”‘ Wolf recalled. “But I said, ‘Look, Sam, it’s the same thing that all of us face at some point. It’s intergenerational. It’s believable.’ You know, I think playing that note is incredibly interesting. It’s handing over power to the next generation.”
Plasma computer screens sit atop desks cluttered with papers, folders, coffee cups and tired old books. A series of hallways leads from the den of offices to a courtroom scattered with wooden witness boxes that the crew will clear for later scenes. Even more passageways lead to the morgue, which contains the requisite storage spaces for dead bodies. The Rikers Island jail is recreated, complete with an admissions office and steely gates through which inmates pass to enter the slammer.
The true star of the set, though, is the squad room, a virtual museum of “Law & Order” nostalgia. Though some NYPD precincts updated their look following the Sept. 11 attacks, Wolf left it alone “because it actually is so emblematic of the show,” Berner said.
Computers displaying screen grabs of Web sites and fingerprint scans are flourishes of the new, yet the old-school grit continues: a retro typewriter; peeling green paint; the worn look of a sign that reads, “N.Y.C. Detectives: the greatest detectives in the WORLD.”
An American flag hangs above a doorway. An empty holding cell, big enough for one, stands next to a bulletin board littered with “Wanted” posters. A coffee pot awaits a refill – and, oddly, there are no doughnuts.
Here, like so many before them, detectives Bernard and Lupo crack cases.
“Ted Sanderson – he did nine years for killing his wife until DNA evidence cleared him last year,” Bernard, wearing a grey suit and stern expression, informs Van Buren as cameras roll for the third take of a one-minute scene in her office.
Bernard, who thinks Sanderson murdered his wife’s ex, tells the boss the suspect drives a white Suffolk County truck (which may be the vehicle that ran over the victim); Lupo, who’s not so sure Sanderson is the guy, stands in the doorway.
Van Buren directs the duo to “take a closer look.”
They file out, and that’s a wrap.
Anderson becomes himself again, laughing boisterously at a personal joke between him and Sisto.
The race to outlive “Gunsmoke” was never so much fun.
Yes, can it?!
Can ‘Law & Order’ outlive ‘Gunsmoke’?